Sonnet 115 – Shakespeare

Shakespeare admits that earlier poems underestimated his love, because language could not foresee how devotion would grow. What once seemed the utmost truth has been surpassed by time and experience, so that past “lies” become proof of love’s expansion. The sonnet turns contradiction into sincerity: love is not false when it changes—its increase is the deepest confirmation.

Sonnet 115 – Read and Listen

⬇️ Download Audio

Those lines that I before have writ do lie,
Even those that said I could not love you dearer:
Yet then my judgment knew no reason why
My most full flame should afterwards burn clearer.

But reckoning time, whose million’d accidents
Creep in ‘twixt vows, and change decrees of kings,
Tan sacred beauty, blunt the sharp’st intents,
Divert strong minds to the course of altering things;

Alas, why fearing of time’s tyranny,
Might I not then say, ‘Now I love you best,’
When I was certain o’er incertainty,
Crowning the present, doubting of the rest?

Love is a babe; then might I not say so,
To give full growth to that which still doth grow?

»»» Introduction to Shakespeare’s Sonnets
»»» Complete Sonnets List
»»» Sonnets in Italian

Introduction to Sonnet 115

Sonnet 115 is Shakespeare’s bold confession that his own earlier poems were “lies.” The word is shocking, yet the sonnet quickly explains its meaning: what once felt like complete love has been surpassed by a deeper, later love. Language was sincere in the past, but it could not predict the future expansion of devotion.

The poem revolves around growth. Shakespeare remembers lines in which he claimed he could not love the beloved more. Those statements were true at the time, because the speaker’s judgment saw no reason why “my most full flame” would later burn even clearer. Love seemed already complete.

Then time enters as a disruptive force. It brings “million’d accidents” that creep between vows, change decrees of kings, blunt intentions, and divert even strong minds. In this world, certainty is fragile. Love therefore faces a double problem: it changes, and the world changes around it.

Instead of treating change as betrayal, Shakespeare reframes it as the sign of living love. The third quatrain asks why he should not have said “Now I love you best” when he felt it, crowning the present while doubting the future. The question is deeply human: how can anyone speak forever when time will always prove speech incomplete?

The final couplet provides the resolution. Love is “a babe.” It must be allowed to grow. The poet could not claim full maturity for something still developing. Sonnet 115 therefore transforms contradiction into honesty: if earlier vows are exceeded, the excess does not expose falsity—it proves love’s capacity to increase.

Analysis — Sonnet 115

First Quatrain — Earlier Lines as “Lies”

The opening statement is deliberately extreme: previous lines “do lie,” even those that said the poet could not love the beloved more. Shakespeare calls them lies not because they were manipulative, but because time has shown them incomplete.

The quatrain clarifies the psychological truth behind this. At the moment of writing, judgment could not imagine a reason why love would intensify further. The metaphor of flame is important: a “most full flame” appears already at its maximum. Yet later it burns “clearer,” suggesting that love can refine itself, becoming brighter and purer with time.

In this way the quatrain stages the sonnet’s paradox: the most sincere “forever” can still be surpassed.

Second Quatrain — Time’s Million Accidents

The second quatrain introduces time as the main agent of change. Its “million’d accidents” creep between vows. The verb “creep” implies stealth, gradual intrusion, and inevitability.

Shakespeare lists time’s effects on every scale. It alters kings’ decrees (political upheaval), tarnishes sacred beauty (aging and decay), blunts sharp intentions (weakening resolve), and diverts strong minds (moral or emotional shifting). Nothing remains fixed.

This catalogue universalizes the poem. Love is not the only thing threatened; everything is. Against such instability, absolute statements become difficult, because life is always rewriting itself.

Third Quatrain — The Right to Crown the Present

The third quatrain turns inward with an anxious “Alas.” Shakespeare asks why, fearing time’s tyranny, he might not say “Now I love you best.” If time will change all things, should the present not be honoured?

The quatrain admits a painful reality: confidence often exists “o’er incertainty,” not above it, but in defiance of it. The poet crowns the present while doubting the future. Love speaks from what it knows now, even though it cannot control what comes.

The quatrain therefore becomes a defense of present truth. Words need not be eternally accurate to be honestly meant.

Final Couplet — Love as a Babe That Must Grow

The couplet resolves the tension with a tender metaphor. Love is a baby. A child cannot be described as finished. Declaring “I love you best” too early would freeze love in a premature form.

The last line—“to give full growth to that which still doth grow”—defines the sonnet’s ethics. Love must be allowed to expand. Earlier poems underestimated love because love itself was still becoming.

Thus the sonnet ends not with contradiction but with maturity: change is not failure; it is the evidence of life.

Conclusion

Sonnet 115 addresses the instability of language in the face of time. Shakespeare calls his earlier poems lies because they claimed a maximum love that later proved exceedable. The confession is not cynical; it is deeply sincere, revealing how devotion grows beyond what words can foresee.

Time is the poem’s great adversary, bringing countless accidents that disrupt vows and reshape the world. Yet the sonnet refuses despair. It argues that the present deserves its crown, even when the future cannot be guaranteed.

In the end, Shakespeare offers a gentle philosophy of love. Love is a babe: it develops, deepens, and expands. When love grows beyond earlier vows, those vows are not exposed as falsehood—they are revealed as the first stages of something stronger. Sonnet 115 makes growth the truest proof of fidelity.

Sonetto 115 – In Italiano ·
◀ Sonnet 114 · Sonnet 116 ▶

PirandelloWeb