Time becomes a lens of comparison as Shakespeare questions whether the present can ever surpass the past, using historical memory to test the uniqueness of love against repetition and inheritance.
Sonnet 59 – Read and Listen
If there be nothing new, but that which is
Hath been before, how are our brains beguiled,
Which labouring for invention bear amiss
The second burthen of a former child!
O, that record could with a backward look,
Even of five hundred courses of the sun,
Show me your image in some antique book,
Since mind at first in character was done!
That I might see what the old world could say
To this composed wonder of your frame;
Whether we are mended, or whether better they,
Or whether revolution be the same.
O, sure I am, the wits of former days,
To subjects worse have given admiring praise.
»»» Introduction to Shakespeare’s Sonnets
»»» Complete Sonnets List
»»» Sonnets in Italian
Introduction to Sonnet 59
Sonnet 59 expands the emotional inquiry of the previous poems into a historical dimension. After examining patience, power, and endurance within personal love, Shakespeare now asks a broader question: is anything truly new, or is the present merely a repetition of what has already been?
The poem confronts time not as an enemy of love, but as a measure of value. By imagining past ages and forgotten records, the speaker tests whether his present experience can claim originality or superiority. Love becomes subject to historical comparison.
Sonnet 59 thus introduces anxiety about uniqueness. The speaker wonders whether his beloved exceeds all previous ideals, or whether admiration itself is constrained by repetition and tradition.
Analysis — Sonnet 59
First Quatrain — Time as Repetition
The opening quatrain presents time as cyclical rather than progressive. Shakespeare suggests that nothing truly escapes recurrence.
If all things repeat, then present excellence may not be exceptional. Love risks becoming derivative.
This idea unsettles the speaker, who seeks confirmation of singular value.
Second Quatrain — Lost Records and Forgotten Praise
In the second quatrain, Shakespeare turns to history’s silence. Past achievements and beauties may have equaled or surpassed the present.
Yet records are incomplete. Memory fails to preserve what once existed.
This absence introduces uncertainty. Comparison becomes speculative rather than definitive.
Third Quatrain — Judgment Across Time
The third quatrain imagines a hypothetical test: if earlier observers could see the present beloved, how would they judge?
This imagined gaze externalizes doubt. The speaker seeks validation beyond his own perspective.
Love desires objective confirmation of its worth.
Final Couplet — Present Love Under Scrutiny
The final couplet offers a tentative conclusion. Either the present surpasses the past, or admiration remains unchanged.
Shakespeare leaves the question open, emphasizing uncertainty rather than triumph.
Conclusion
Sonnet 59 introduces a reflective pause in the sequence, shifting attention from emotional endurance to historical comparison. Shakespeare interrogates the desire to believe in the uniqueness of present love.
The poem suggests that admiration is shaped by time’s cycles as much as by individual feeling. Love seeks distinction, yet it operates within inherited patterns.
By placing love under the scrutiny of history, Sonnet 59 deepens the sequence’s philosophical scope. Love endures, but it does so amid doubts about originality, continuity, and the limits of human praise.
Sonetto 59 – In Italiano ·
◀ Sonnet 58 · Sonnet 60 ▶
Sonnet by William Shakespeare.
Text and audio are in the public domain.
LibriVox recording.
All LibriVox recordings are in the public domain.
For more information, or to volunteer, please visit
LibriVox.org.
Read by Elizabeth Klett.
